The Subaru Forester entered the U.S. market in 1997 and quickly became a class favorite. Combining the practicality of a wagon with the capabilities of a rugged SUV, it set itself apart with its notorious all-wheel-drive system and reliability. Over the years, the Forester earned a reputation for safety and durability. While most Foresters offer strong value, some model years stand out for exceptional reliability and owner satisfaction. Here are seven of the best Subaru Forester years based on performance, dependability, and overall experience.

2009 Subaru Forester

The 2009 Subaru Forester debuted the third generation with a much-needed overhaul. It featured a longer wheelbase, translating to more interior space and better handling on the road. Subaru also upgraded the suspension, creating a smoother ride without sacrificing the Forester’s rugged off-road capabilities.

The 2009 Forester offered two engine options: the standard 2.5-liter 4-cylinder engine with 170 horsepower and a turbocharged version that delivered 224 horsepower for those seeking extra performance. Both engines paired with Subaru’s signature all-wheel-drive system, making it ideal for winter weather or unpaved trails.

What set the 2009 Forester apart was its improved safety. It earned a coveted Top Safety Pick designation from the IIHS, thanks to strong crash-test ratings and standard safety features like side-curtain airbags and stability control. This model avoided many of the reliability issues seen in earlier generations, making it a favorite among used SUV buyers.

2010 Subaru Forester

The 2010 Subaru Forester maintained the third-generation upgrades while addressing minor issues from 2009. It retained the spacious interior and strong safety credentials, making it a family-friendly choice. The large greenhouse-style windows provided excellent visibility, a feature that earned praise from drivers and reviewers alike.

One reason the 2010 model stands out is its durability. Owners have reported that, with regular maintenance, this model can last well over 200,000 miles. Unlike some earlier Forester years, the 2010 version avoided significant engine problems, particularly head gasket failures that plagued other Subaru models.

In terms of features, it provided buyers with options like a premium audio system, leather upholstery, and an available sunroof. For those seeking a turbocharged engine, the XT trim remained an exciting choice, delivering sporty performance while keeping the practicality of a compact SUV.

2015 Subaru Forester

The 2015 Subaru Forester built on the strengths of the fourth generation while resolving some of the issues reported in earlier models. Most notably, Subaru addressed the oil consumption concerns that affected specific 2014 vehicles, making the 2015 version a more reliable choice for buyers.

The 2015 Forester offered the same fuel-efficient CVT transmission and standard all-wheel drive, earning high praise for its stability in various driving conditions. It achieved impressive fuel economy, with up to 32 mpg on the highway, without compromising the power of its 2.5-liter engine. For those seeking more performance, the turbocharged XT model remained an exciting option, delivering 250 horsepower.

Inside, the 2015 Forester continued to impress with its spacious, user-friendly cabin. It offered excellent visibility thanks to large windows and a high driving position. Safety was another strong point, with the Forester earning a Top Safety Pick+ designation from the IIHS when equipped with the optional EyeSight Driver Assist system. These qualities made the 2015 Subaru Forester a dependable and practical choice for families and outdoor enthusiasts alike.

2016 Subaru Forester

By 2016, Subaru had refined the fourth-generation Forester into one of the most well-rounded SUVs on the market. The EyeSight system became more widely available and included additional safety features like lane-keeping assist and sway warning. These upgrades helped the 2016 Forester earn a Top Safety Pick+ award from the IIHS.

Performance-wise, the Forester continued to offer two engine options. The base 2.5-liter engine provided reliable power and excellent efficiency, while the turbocharged XT model delivered an engaging driving experience. Subaru also tweaked the suspension, improving ride comfort and road handling.

This model year stood out for its quiet cabin, thanks to added insulation that reduced road noise. Drivers praised the Forester for its excellent visibility, spacious interior, and smooth ride, all of which made it a practical daily driver. Compared to competitors in its class, the 2016 Forester delivered an unbeatable combination of reliability, safety, and value.

2017 Subaru Forester

Subaru made subtle but meaningful improvements with the 2017 Forester. A refreshed front-end design gave it a modern look, while additional noise insulation enhanced cabin comfort. Subaru also introduced torque vectoring to the turbocharged XT model, improving cornering stability and handling for performance enthusiasts.

The 2017 Forester retained its reputation for safety, earning a Top Safety Pick+ rating once again. New features, like automatic high beams and reverse automatic braking, added to its suite of safety technology. These updates appealed to families and commuters who prioritized peace of mind on the road.

In terms of reliability, the 2017 Forester avoided major complaints related to engine or transmission issues. Routine maintenance kept these SUVs running smoothly, and owners frequently praised their durability and fuel efficiency. The combination of practicality, safety, and low ownership costs made the 2017 Forester a standout in the lineup.

2019 Subaru Forester

The 2019 Forester marked the start of the fifth generation, built on Subaru’s new global platform. This redesign resulted in a quieter ride, improved crash safety, and a stiffer chassis for better handling. Subaru also upgraded the engine, offering a 2.5-liter Boxer engine with 182 horsepower and increased efficiency.

One of the highlights of the 2019 Forester was its advanced technology. Standard EyeSight Driver Assist features included lane centering, pre-collision braking, and adaptive cruise control. Subaru also added a DriverFocus system that used facial recognition to detect driver fatigue or distraction.

Inside, the cabin felt more spacious than ever, with thoughtful touches like rear USB ports and increased cargo capacity. Owners loved the balance of comfort and capability, making this model year ideal for road trips, daily commutes, and outdoor adventures.

2021 Subaru Forester

The 2021 Forester built on the strengths of the fifth generation while adding minor but meaningful upgrades. Adaptive LED headlights became standard, improving nighttime visibility. Subaru’s symmetrical all-wheel drive remained a key feature, offering excellent traction in snow, rain, and rough terrain.

Drivers appreciated the Forester’s fuel efficiency, which remained competitive at up to 33 mpg on the highway. Inside, the spacious cabin offered supportive seating and ample legroom, even for tall passengers. The intuitive infotainment system made it easy to stay connected on the go, with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto integration as standard features.

Safety was a highlight, with the 2021 Forester earning high marks from the IIHS and NHTSA. Owners also reported high satisfaction with its reliability, noting few issues over time. Its combination of modern technology, safety, and practicality cemented the 2021 Forester as a top choice for buyers.

While we’re here, if you’re shopping for a good used Forester, be sure to check out MotorBiscuit’s seamless car buying tool to compare prices and find the best deal in your area.

Choosing the best Subaru Forester year depends on your budget and needs. However, these seven model years consistently earn praise for reliability, safety, and owner satisfaction. From the rugged 2009 model to the tech-savvy 2021 Forester, each year offers something unique. Whether you’re a family seeking a safe and spacious SUV or an outdoor enthusiast craving all-weather capability, the Subaru Forester remains a trusted choice.